News Photos
Search Advanced Sign in / Register fans
Two judges' sympathy for elderly prostitutes leads to law revision
Central News Agency
2009-11-07 06:24 PM
Taipei, Nov. 7 (CNA) For years, prostitutes caught in police raids in Taiwan were punished under the law, while their clients walked free. However, this law was challenged as "unfair" by two judges in a recent case involving two elderly prostitutes, and the justices' petition for a judicial review has led to an upcoming change in the rules.

The Constitutional Court decided Friday that the relevant article in the Social Order Maintenance Act violates the principle of equality enshrined in the Constitution, and that new regulations should be worked out by the administration and the legislature.

As amendment of the regulations and penalties pertaining to prostitution requires administrative and legislative review and planning, the Constitutional Court ruled that the existing law will be retained for two more years until Nov. 5, 2011.

Meanwhile, the judges suggested that the police and judicial authorities show "leniency" when dealing with the punishment of prostitutes, whom they described as socially disadvantaged individuals.

Under the existing act, law enforcement authorities may detain a prostitute for a maximum of three days or impose a fine of up to NT$30,000. Prostitutes could also be sent to reform institutions for a period of six months to a year, under the law.

According to the two Yilan District Court judges, Lin Chun-ting and Yang Kun-chiao, over the years they have encountered many cases of elderly prostitutes earning a mere NT$300 for each transaction, and in those cases prostitution was not really a choice but rather the only way to earn a living.

Out of pity for such prostitutes who face legal penalties, the two judges took the issue to the Constitutional Court, questioning the fairness of the law that absolves the clients of prostitutes.

The Constitutional Court's decision may give momentum to Taiwan's gender equality groups that have been calling for prostitution to be decriminalized.

When the decriminalization proposal was raised by Kuomintang Legislator Cheng Li-wen at the Legislative Yuan in mid June, some lawmakers suggested setting up special sex-industry zones, similar to the red-light districts in Amsterdam and Hamburg. However, most other legislators expressed reservations about the suggestion.

(By Lin Shen-hsu and Lillian Lin)



 
Have Your Say :

We welcome your comments on this and other stories. Comments are submitted for possible publication on the condition that they may be edited. Please provide your full name and suburb/location. We also require a working e-mail address – not for publication, but for verification only.

 
Post your feedback
 
 
More Society Stories
Chinese Culture Minister Cai visits Taiwan   2010-09-03
Chi-Yen Community's successful storyStaying green calls for everyone's involvement   2010-09-03
Taiwanese director nominated for Seoul drama awards   2010-09-03
National Palace Museum to be expanded   2010-09-03
Tsao picked up at airport as witness in game-fixing scandal   2010-09-03
Taiwanese student invents free photography software for the blind   2010-09-03
FPG offer of NT$252 million compensation accepted   2010-09-02
President approves resignation of advisor   2010-09-02
Taiwan baseball star picked up at airport as witness in game-fixing scandal   2010-09-02
Taiwan student invents free photography software for the blind   2010-09-02
Talk of the day -- Why Taiwan's highways are riddled with pits   2010-09-02
Environmental groups call for green traffic   2010-09-02
Taipei and Paris film commissions ink deal   2010-09-02
Greenhouse gas   2010-09-02
Taiwan ranked 'mostly free'   2010-09-02
Chinatrust calls reports of China control exaggerated   2010-09-02
Judicial Yuan appointee denies allegations of research funds misuse   2010-09-02
Lionrock to bring heavy rains to southern Taiwan   2010-09-02
KMT lawmakers criticize Wu over praise for leave without pay   2010-09-02
State-run refiner, research unit sign green energy pact   2010-09-01
 
01     02   03   04   05   Next   >
 
To search for articles form the past seven days, Click on ARCHIVES
Advertisement
7day free